by Captain Thark » Thu Feb 15, 2007 2:33 am
HERETIC! HERETIC! HERTIC!
Battlestar Galactica is a repetive mess of a show that fails to have likable characters with a plot that boils down to "Evil Robots are killing us." "lets look for a planet that may not even exist!" "Okay, hope no-turns out to be a robot!".
The charcaters of Battlestar Galactica are nothing but a combination of clichés and random flaws, with the supposed main charachters being a wishy-washy and anoying and a drunken, spoiled, clichéd prophised-one, respectively.
The show is almost saved by Adama, but his awesomeness is reduced by the fact that he's already so close to a dozen anime captains of the "Hard School of Heroes" archetype.
Firefly is, while not without a few clichés of it's own, creates a universe unlike any other scifi show. For the first time there's no sound in space! Every charcter is deep, with histories and secrets far more interesting than "are they a robot?".
The writing is superb, with Joss Wheden using every trick he learned on Buffy and Angel to it's fullest extent. There are no aliens or robots to be passed off as villians, no all the monsters out in the Black are human. The Aliance is far more interesting than the Cylons.
Battlestar Galactica, while a decent show, is hardly the groundbreaking show many people would have you believe. It tries to convince you it's adult by waving abortion and 'frack' in your face.
I'd much rther be caugt up in the unique and interesting world of the 'verse.
YOU CAN'T TAKE THE SKY FROM ME!
This rant was brought to you by your freindly local Joss Wheden fanboy, who would like to remind you that the look of Battlestar Galactica rips off Firefly, so much so a Firefly class starship even apeared in Battlestar Galactica!
We now return you to our reguarly scheduled Anime-ness, sorry for the rant but to parphrase Scotty: He insulted ma favorite scifi Captain!.
P.S. Even Farscape and Babylon Five are better! And sometimes Andromeda!
This sword calls me it's master, but I feel more like it's slave.